• SC Dimona 23 – 22 Shimshon Tel Aviv: 56 penalties (2024)
  • Washington 25 – 24 Bedlington: 54 kicks – 2022
  • KK Palace 17 – 16 The Civics: 48 penalties (2005)
  • Old Wulfrunians 19 – 18 Lane Head: 44 penalties (2021)
  • Preston North End 16-15: 34 penalties (2024)*
  • Netherlands U21 13 – 12 England U21: 32 penalties (2007)
  • Scunthorpe 14 – 13 Worcester: 32 penalties (2014)
  • Liverpool 14 – 13 Middlesbrough: 30 penalties (2014)
  • Olympiacos 15 – 14 AEK Athens: 30 penalties (2008)
  • Brockenhurst 15 – 14 Andover Town: 30 penalties (2013)